读书的海报:美国的学术评价

来源:百度文库 编辑:九乡新闻网 时间:2024/04/27 18:08:49

美国的学术评价

刘岩

 

我多次在《科学网》上说,美国的学术评价体系是看论文发表后的学术影响力,不和论文发表的刊物档次,引用次数这些中国学者引以为豪的东西挂钩,不少人表示不理解。

我同时又说,西方学术评价的核心内容是看教授,研究人员获得学术奖励,学术荣誉的多少,以及档次为标准,《科学网》上不少人表示反对。

我这里就不和这些人争辩了,俗话说,事实胜于雄辩,我就将美国化学学会主办的两份顶级刊物,一份是环境科学顶级刊物《环境科学与技术》,另一份是国际分析化学顶级刊物《分析化学》两位主编,前者是美国工程院院士,后者是美国科学院院士,两人的简历从他们的个人简历中拷贝下来,放在下面,供大家评价,看看这两个人共获得过多少学术奖励,学术荣誉。

Environmental Science&Technology主编J Schnoor

Honors and Accolades
  • University of Iowa Faculty Scholar, 1980-83
  • Walter L. Huber Research Prize, American Society of Civil Engineers, 1985
  • Who's Who in America, 44th Edition, 1986-
  • Diplomate, American Academy of Environmental Engineers, 1990-
  • Best Paper Awards, EPA Region 7/8 HSRC, 1991 and 1995
  • Jimmy Quon Memorial Lecture, Northwestern University, 1992
  • Iowa Regent's Award for Faculty Excellence, 1992
  • Distinguished Fellow Award, Iowa Academy of Science (highest honor), 1996
  • Presidential Lecturer, University of Iowa, 1996
  • Professional Achievement Citation in Engineering, Iowa State University, 1996
  • Rudolph Hering Medal, Am. Society of Civil Engineers, 1998
  • Association Environmental Engineering Professors, Distinguished Lecturer Award, 1998
  • Montgomery-Watson Best M.S. Thesis/Advisor Award (w/ Eric Aitchison), AEEP, 1998
  • National Academy of Engineering, 1999-
  • Sigma Xi Distinguished Lecturer, 1999-2000
  • Hancher Finkbine Medallion, 2000
  • Henske Distinguished Lecturer, Yale University, 2000
  • Feng Distinguished Lecturer, U. Massachusetts, 2000

(注:此此人的学术荣誉里有Who's Who,科学网上有人贬低这个东西,呵呵,没道理吧)

Analytical Chemsitry主编 R Murry

Honors and Accolades
  • Southern Chemist Award, 2008
  • Centenary Lecturer of The Royal Society of Chemistry (medal), 2005
  • Luigi Galvani Medal of the Italian Chemical Society, 2004
  • Ralph and Helen Oesper Award, University of Cincinnati, 2002
  • Pittsburgh Award in Analytical Chemistry, Pittsburgh Society of Analytical Chemists, 2002
  • National Associate of the National Academies, 2001
  • North Carolina Award for Science (Governor’s Award), 2001
  • Festschrift Issue of the Journal of Physical Chemistry B, 2001
  • Thomas Jefferson Award, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 2001
  • Olin Palladium Medal, The Electrochemical Society, 1997
  • Breyer Medal, Electrochemistry Division of the Royal Australian Chemical Institute, 1997
  • Eastern Analytical Symposium Award in the Fields of Analytical Chemistry, 1995
  • Fellow of The Electrochemical Society, elected 1995
  • Fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, elected 1992
  • Fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, elected 1992
  • Member of the National Academy of Sciences, elected 1991
  • ACS Award in Analytical Chemistry, 1991
  • ACS Division of Analytical Chemistry Award in Electrochemistry, 1990
  • Eleventh North Carolina ACS Section Distinguished Speaker Award, 1989
  • Electrochemical Group Medal of the Royal Society of Chemistry, London, 1989
  • Charles N. Reilley Award of the Society for Electroanalytical Chemistry, 1988
  • The Electrochemical Society Carl Wagner Memorial Award, 1987
  • Fellow, American Institute of Chemists, 1986
  • Distinguished North Carolina Chemist Award, North Carolina Institute of Chemists, 1987
  • John Simon Guggenheim Fellow, 1980-1981
  • Fellow, Japanese Society for the Promotion of Science Research, 1978
  • Alfred P. Sloan Research Fellow, 1969-1972